The song appeared on Cain’s drone album, Perverts, which came out earlier this year.
By Andy Kahn Aug 19, 2025 • 7:22 am PDT
Ethel Cain brought The Willoughby Tucker Forever Tour to Berkeley, California’s Greek Theatre on Monday night. The concert featured Chelsea Wolfe joining Cain on a performance of “Punish.”
Cain’s tour takes its name from her album Willoughby Tucker, I’ll Always Love You, which was released two weeks ago. “Punish” appeared on Cain’s other 2025 release, the drone album Perverts that came out in January.
Last November, Wolfe participated in an “Ask Me Anything (AMA)” session on Reddit and was asked, “Who is an artist you’d love to collaborate with?” Wolfe’s response included mention of Ethel Cain.
The collab materialized last night when Cain said to the audience at The Greek, “Berkeley, please welcome to the stage, Chelsea Wolfe.” After they collaborated on “Punish,” Cain added, “Ethel Cain wouldn’t exist without Chelsea Wolfe.”
Check out audience-captured footage of the pair performing “Punish” together here:
-
Willoughby’s Theme
-
Janie
-
Fuck Me Eyes
-
Nettles
-
Willoughby’s Interlude
-
Dust Bowl
-
Punish
-
Onanist
-
A Knock at the Door
-
Radio Towers
-
Tempest
-
Waco, Texas
-
A House in Nebraska
-
Crush
-
American Teenager
-
A Quick One Before the Eternal Worm Devours Appalachia
Setlist data setlist.fm.
